Conventional Lending Won’t Do for MSMEs

Medium, Small, and Micro Enterprises (MSMEs) are undoubtedly essential pieces of a low-income country’s economic development. In developing nations, MSMEs contribute up to 40% of gross domestic product (GDP) and 70% to employment creation.

Surprisingly, there aren’t extensive studies that assess the contribution of MSMEs to Ethiopia’s economy. However, some reports indicate micro and small enterprises (MSEs) are the second-largest employment-generating sector next to agriculture, employing an estimated 4.5 million people. 

A precise count seems difficult to find, but there are an estimated 850,000 MSMEs in Ethiopia, with 85% being micro enterprises. The number is growing by the day as well. Within the first nine months of 2021/22, the Ethiopian Enterprise Development announced the establishment of 2,907 new manufacturing MSMEs. 

MSMEs undeniably impact the economy, but they are being left out of a crucial piece of the growth equation – access to finance. The nature of their growth trajectory inhibits them from qualifying for conventional lending.

An analysis of the loan portfolios of financial institutions showcases the problem. For many years, the credit availed by financial institutions to MSMEs has remained quite low. 

In the second quarter of the current fiscal year, 25.8% of new bank loans were disbursed to enterprises involved in international trading. This has been a long-standing practice in the financial sector. Similarly, 20% went to similar business lines last year. Moreover, more than half of commercial bank loans have been used to fund public projects, reducing significantly the credit available to the private sector.

Yet, thousands of MSMEs in multiple productive sectors of the economy are facing insurmountable financing gaps. 

The 2018 SME Finance Forum estimated that the MSME finance gap in Ethiopia is $4.2 billion, with small and medium enterprises accounting for over 90% while micro enterprises made up the remaining. The amount could potentially be more now, considering the inflation rate and the increasing number of MSMEs. 

MSME Lending Can be Profitable

Microfinance institutions have generally been tasked with the responsibility of providing funding to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), as their design is more geared toward meeting the financing needs of the underbanked. But MFI borrowing is generally characterized by high-interest rates.

Banks on their part, have tended to consider financing MSMEs a part of their corporate social responsibility. This has resulted in a lack of innovative products that address the core challenges with traditional lending that have prevented banks from extending a significant amount of credit to MSMEs. Specifically, alternatives to standard credit worthiness analysis and loan collection have been barely explored. 

The push factor here should be the commercial profitability of lending to MSMEs. If banks can reduce loan costs through digital solutions and devise a less costly loan collection method, lending to MSMEs will be as profitable as lending to other businesses.

Conventional lending poses high collateral requirements 

Among numerous operational and supply-side hurdles, MSMEs in Ethiopia say a core challenge they face is lack of financing.

Only 6% of micro enterprises, 1.9% of small enterprises, and 20.5% of medium enterprises have a loan or a line of credit according to a study published in 2015. 

The same study explored the reasons why these enterprises are not taking out loans. Chief among them is high collateral requirements set by lending institutions. Collateral requirements can sometimes amount to as high as 350% of the loan. 

In recent years there have been laudable attempts to ease collateral requirements spearheaded by the government and some financial institutions. 

In 2020, the central bank introduced a movable collateral scheme. It required banks to allocate at least 5% of annual loan disbursement, against movable assets, to individuals, persons and unions in the agriculture sector and MSMEs. However, the performance of this scheme is yet to be analyzed.  

The rise of capital goods financing schemes is also a positive development, especially for the manufacturing sector, which requires heavy capital goods financing. There are six capital goods financing companies in Ethiopia. In addition, the state-owned Development Bank of Ethiopia is engaged in capital goods financing mainly targeting SMEs.

Ultimately, the task of revolutionizing lending to serve non-traditional customer bases will fall upon tech companies, but as seen in other countries, partnerships between banks, FinTechs, and regulators are key. 

Ethiopia’s 10-year perspective plan wants to pave way for the establishment of two million micro enterprises by 2030. 10% of these are expected to grow into small enterprises while 1% are planned to grow into medium enterprises. 

If this ambitious goal is to be achieved, financial institutions and FinTechs must let go of archaic lending models and adopt alternatives that truly suit their clients’ needs.