Expansion of DFS, why so Sluggish?

In terms of overall economic growth, Ethiopia is going forward. It’s among the top 10 largest African economies, exhibiting consistent annual growth.  

A population of 120 million people, it represents a significant opportunity for digital and financial service providers. Yet, the fintech industry in Ethiopia remains nascent.

Let’s see some indicators:

Financial inclusion

Ethiopia has one of the lowest account ownerships in Africa. Not only that, but the tendency to heavily rely on cash transactions in Ethiopia is excessive.

Ethiopia: approximately 50% of the adult population

Kenya: >82%

Nigeria: ~65%

SouthAfrica: ~89%

Funding

According to a report published by Disrupt Africa, African Fintechs received one billion dollars in funding in 2021. 80pc of the funding went to four countries only: Nigeria, South Africa, Egypt, and Kenya. 

Fintech funding to Ethiopia is barely mentioned in the report, with ArfiPay being the only company to make the list. This not only reflects the small amount of funds raised in Ethiopia but also the availability of data on these transactions.

Startup funding

Ethiopia: $3.5m

Kenya: $62m

SA: $205m

Nigeria: 36.5m

Payment trend

Ethiopians heavily rely on cash transactions despite the recently introduced cash holding restrictions. The recent currency change has brought over 30 billion birr into the banking system. But by the second quarter of 2021/22 currency circulating outside the banking system reached 158 billion birr.

 

From : World Bank, Global Findex Database

In an attempt to understand the different facets of why Ethiopia is lagging behind, we sought the opinions of industry experts and professionals.

Ermias Wodajo

Ermias is a corporate lawyer who keeps a close eye on the financial sector.  

Why is Ethiopia lagging behind? The answer depends on who’s asked. If you forward it to Mastercard Foundation, which is working on access to Digital Payment in sub-Saharan Africa with the goal of helping small businesses and entrepreneurs achieve payment digitization, the answer will revolve around the lack of enabling systems (Digital ID) and facilitating digital interactions between government, private sector, and citizens.  

If you ask an Indian or/and Nigerian fintech start ups, they will answer by inquiring how fintech could evolve in Ethiopia where there exists the highest cost of mobile data, without a national identification program, without an open-source application program interface (API), and lower adoption of digital payments.

 If you ask European Investment Bank, which had invested €3 million in M-BIRR in 2018, the answer will evolve around the effectiveness of the business model in terms of social impact- whether the business model will enable access to finance to those not covered by traditional banks. The bank would argue the growth of the sector and the funding that goes to it will be realized depending on the viability of the business model adopted.

If you ask Kifiya Financial Technology, which has succeeded in unifying the billing system of basic government services, will spell the problem as ‘fragmented fintech and lack of an ecosystem that brings various stakeholders in one system’. They will refer to M-PESA’s success in the integration of all ecosystems and all stakeholders as one in its ecosystem.

 If you ask Arifpay, the first licensed fintech that came up with integrated internet-based and point-of-sale transactions, the problem for fintechs was the lack of interoperability between bank accounts and the National Bank of Ethiopia’s lack of legal recognition of fintech until April 2020. 

If you ask CashGo and GuzoGo which provide international remittance, e-ticketing, e-payment services, the problem lies in the failure to build an end-to-end payment ecosystem. While the consumer is onboard for digital transactions, all of the merchants are not there in the system. Those absent include wholesalers, retailers, importers, industries and commodity suppliers.

While banks are integrated through Ethswitch, the fintechs are unable to integrate the whole merchants (companies) on the fintech ecosystem. This shows the need for a legal framework for merchants and creating an ecosystem that can seamlessly integrate full-fledged digital marketplaces, payment technologies, tax systems, banks, suppliers and other regulators together.

Tewodros Tassew

Tewodros is Consultant specializing in Digital Financial Services. He has been working in the DFS space for over 10 years.

Comparing other African countries to the Ethiopian market which did not recognize fintechs as financial service providers until recently may not be fair. It is not an apple-to-apple comparison.

Banks and a few technology companies have played and continue to play a role in fintech offering a range of technology-based financial solutions. For long, the banks and MFIs were the ones who were providing financial offerings while typical fintechs were unable to do so. Now things are changing and fintechs are assuming the service provider role and we are already seeing a lot of excitement in the market.

When it comes to access to funding where local VC firms are almost non-existent and while the sector is restricted for foreign investment, local fintech’s were limited to raising funds locally which often doesn’t get reported. The problem with attaining funding is prevalent but the amount of funding that fintech’s are raising isn’t publicly disclosed which makes comparison with regional markets difficult.
Looking at the growth of digital transactions, the fintech space is experiencing significant growth. Looking at transaction growth from CBE and Ethswitch is a good indicator in this regard.

Anonymous

A digital banking expert from the banking industry. 

The funding gap is caused by the companies’ inability to accept foreign investment. Perhaps, the new policy direction that allows foreign nationals to provide digital financial services will solve the issue. In addition to the legal barrier, the sector is not big enough to accept funding. Investors that are pumping big money into African startups are looking for scalability. These startups have been in operation testing and scaling their products for years. How many of these companies are there in Ethiopia?

When it comes to the slow expansion of digital financial services, the business model adopted is the crux of the problem. Customers have become so accustomed to free services that banks struggle to transition to commission-based pricing.

In contrast to other countries, the banking industry focuses mainly on loan interest model as opposed to the commission model.

As of now, we cannot charge merchants interchange fees because they will just resort to cash payments. This is where the government could come in and incentivize business owners. It could offer lower taxes for these merchants. For one, digital payments provide complete transparency of books. The difference can be compensated for through taxing banks.

The biggest commitment to transforming digital financial services has to come from the government. This can be achieved by taking government services fully online.  If Kebeles start asking for digital payments to issue IDs, people would make the shift to digital and actually keep money in their accounts.